24 August 2026
“Publishers and sociologists underestimate today’s Russian reader”
Alexander Zhuravsky on “Alternative”, futurology, dystopias, the business elite and the political thriller as a genre.
“Publishers and sociologists underestimate today’s Russian reader”
We publish a conversation between the publisher Nikita Tomilin and the historian and scholar of religion Alexander Zhuravsky (pictured), author of the futurological novel “Alternative”. The book reached marketplaces and bookshop shelves only in December of last year, yet it has already become a literary event and a bestseller, selling 17,000 copies, which by today’s standards is a spectacular success. “Alternative” has received warm responses from readers and good press. Its protagonist is Kirill Ratnikov, a veteran of the special military operation who finds himself in the future, in 2033.
– What was your main motivation for writing the book? Did you want to say something that others would not? Isn’t it premature to touch on the themes raised in your futurological novel “Alternative”?
– The main motivation was a wish to present a vivid literary image of a future world order in which Russia has the standing of one of three global centres of power, while weaving past, present and future into a single literary fabric: a convincing futurological scenario written in living Russian literary language.
I had no intention of saying what others would not, since I cannot answer for anyone else’s publicity or silence. It seems to me that a serious statement is not born of a vain wish to report something that others will not report. It is born of the impossibility of not saying what overflows in the author. And if it so happens that the book meets a heartfelt and intellectual response from readers, and also touches on themes about which other contemporary books mostly keep silent, the effect is one of literary novelty.
A multi-genre work that unites the political and spy thriller, the adventure novel, the love drama, the parable and the war novel, and that in effect created a new literary genre, the futurological novel, arose from the need to realise a multi-genre design, not from a narcissistic wish to be unlike everyone else. I wanted an intelligent hypertext novel to appear, one that people of different ages and life experience would read thoughtfully, one that would make contemporaries change the pace of their lives, immerse themselves in a literary world of the future and reflect on existential questions. I intended to write about the special military operation in such a way that, without didacticism, a veteran of it would become the hero of our time and of the time to come. How far that succeeded is for the reader to judge.
As for prematurity. Nowadays, it seems, nobody frames the question that way. But in 2022–2024, while the novel was still being written, I repeatedly encountered the position of certain cultural figures and producers who insisted that writing or filming about the war was premature: first we must win, then comprehend and reflect on the results. Then as now, I am convinced that prematurity is a subjective notion. Of course there were, are and will be opportunistic works, but in most cases the authors who write are the ones who cannot not write, when they feel an authorial need. Those who can refrain from writing usually do.
Sholokhov began his unfinished novel “They Fought for Their Country” as early as 1942–1944, describing the tragic retreat of the Soviet troops, because he could not not write. And Ivan Pyryev’s film “At Six O’Clock in the Evening After the War” reached the screens on 16 November 1944, although it contains the scene of the characters played by Ladynina and Samoilov meeting on the Kamenny Bridge in Moscow in May 1945 to the sound of the victory salute. Some will call that Soviet propaganda; I call it the scripting of the coming Victory and a futurological forecast by the director that came true. The Victory and the salute did indeed take place in May 1945.
And one more thought that seems obvious to me. Across the world, and here too, the dystopia is a very popular genre: a toxic, totalitarian future, most often with a condemnation of statism and paternalism in their deliberately exaggerated, Leviathan-like forms. In most of those novels humanity is destined for a sad fate that cannot be changed. On the one hand this breeds decadent moods in society; on the other, a psychology of defeat, because the authors of dystopias paint worlds of an insurmountable, total cancellation of the human being. Where is social optimism to come from? Fantasy seems a more optimistic genre, but to me it is a form of cultural and social escapism, whereas good science fiction is a genre of active dynamism, of faith in the future and in the human being. It is no accident that the Soviet Union, like today’s China, gave such support to science fiction and to films based on the work of its own writers.
– The novel is in many ways prophetic. Or should one say visionary? A prophet warns in order to change the future. A visionary writer describes in order to fix it. Which of these roles do you try on?
– I do not know who in their right mind could call themselves a prophet. A prophet is a preacher of divine revelation chosen by God, a denouncer of human and social vices, a herald of divine judgement. It is absurd to try on the role of a prophet. Incidentally, the prophet does not try to change the future; that is not in his power but in the power of the One in whose name he prophesies. A seer, too, has a special gift. I do not consider myself one. The modern notion of a “visionary”, someone who anticipates trends, is somewhat closer. But the role of the futurologist is probably the best match for what I do as a lecturer and for what I have proposed in the futurological novel “Alternative”.
In the novel I take emerging trends and extrapolate their possible consequences onto an image of the future. Hence my definition of a separate genre, the futurological novel: futurology is a field of knowledge about the future presented in forecasts and scenarios. My novel, likewise, is a literary image of the future presented in scenarios.
Formally, the term “futurology” was introduced into scholarship by the sociologist Ossip Flechtheim, a compatriot of ours born in Nikolaev who later emigrated to Germany and the United States. A student of Carl Schmitt who corresponded with Erich Fromm and Isaac Asimov, Flechtheim first used the term in a letter to Aldous Huxley. But as early as 1926 the Russian economist Nikolai Kondratiev, author of the theory of long economic cycles, wrote of a “theory of foresight”. Most researchers, though, believe that futurology owes more to the science fiction writer H. G. Wells, who coined the phrase “the science of the future” and, in part, the modern term “foresight”.
I would note that futurology, not being a science in the strict sense of the word, owes a great deal precisely to science fiction writers and utopians. Vladimir Odoevsky, the Russian writer, philanthropist, musicologist and mystic whom his contemporaries called “the Russian Faust”, wrote (though did not finish) the futurological tale “The Year 4338: Petersburg Letters” as early as 1835, giving a technological and geopolitical description of the future. Curiously, in that future the world’s centres of power are Russia and China, and Moscow and Petersburg have merged into a single megalopolis.
And the absolute classic of futurology is two works by Stanisław Lem: the first, “Summa Technologiae”, ahead of its time in its technological forecasts (self-learning artificial intelligence, genetic engineering, virtual reality), and the second, “Moloch”, an analysis of the predictions that did and did not come true thirty years on. It is hard not to notice that the title of the first boldly echoes Thomas Aquinas’s “Summa Theologiae”.
– Who do you see as your ideal reader?
– The ideal reader is one who has read the book and retained a need to return to it again and again. In thoughts, quotations, the images of its characters. It is an intelligent, thoughtful reader who is interested in Russia’s future and is not afraid of genre experiments and long literary distances.
Some of those who read the novel in manuscript regretted that such a big novel would be beyond young readers used to consuming fast content on social media. But as practice has shown, the futurological novel turns out to interest readers in their thirties and their eighties, political scientists and soldiers, superbly educated people with academic degrees and students who are still very young. It seems to me that publishers and sociologists underestimate today’s Russian reader. The non-fiction boom we have seen in recent years is partly connected with an awakened interest in history and science, and with the expectation of major literary works on the existential themes that trouble people.
– How did your colleagues and superiors react to the book?
– Little differently from the general readership. Some were delighted and had not expected it. Some had not read it. Some find the reading heavy going, and some are put off by the size of a book for which it is hard to find free time at our frantic pace of life. One should not overrate the significance of a single novel.
– The writer Prilepin said you painted too rosy a picture of Russia’s future. That it reassures the reader too much, when one ought to sound the alarm and warn of dangers, as Kochetov did in “What Is It You Want?”. What do you think?
– Not everyone has to sound the alarm, and not everyone has to be editor-in-chief of the journal “Oktyabr”. Not everyone has to teach, prophesy and denounce, just as not everyone has to sing of Cossack freedom. But I think you are simplifying Zakhar’s position. He said something else about the novel too: “A hyper-relevant, intelligent, fast-moving text.” As I see it, “Alternative” does not offer a rosy future but an attractive image of one, which does not reassure the reader but makes them think hard, because that attractive image has its own high price. And it is not the only scenario of what is to come; there are others, and if they are realised the future becomes a dreadful dystopia. That sobers many readers.
– You are compared with Vladislav Surkov, who under a pseudonym wrote the novella “Uncle Vanya”, in which he recorded the end of the Russian business elite’s illusions about the West. What did you want to record?
– I have not heard of such a comparison. Judging by the capital of business elite figures that was frozen abroad at the start of the special military operation, part of our elite still held those illusions about the West in 2022. How sobering that “cancellation” of Russian business has been for them, time will tell. Secondly, someone called the novella by Nathan Dubovitsky you mention “a forerunner of the literature of the fugitives”, that is, of the new emigration. But I do not recall the author recording the end of anyone’s illusions about the West in it. The novella, I think, is not about that at all. Thirdly, there is an image of émigré life in my novel too, but it is neither the only nor the main line of the book. So the novel is hard to compare with the novella.
– There was information online that the Hollywood actor Armie Hammer is auditioning for a role in the screen adaptation of your novel. Is it true?
– It is too early to talk about casting, since no final decision on an adaptation has been taken, although there are offers from producers.
– Why do you think topical political and spy thrillers are not being made in our country now? There is certainly an interest in the genre.
– On the one hand, producers insist that the domestic audience will not watch the genre in large numbers. That the success of “House of Cards” and “The Diplomat” is down to Netflix’s huge audience, that of “Madam Secretary” and “The West Wing” to the superb work of the producer-writers Barbara Hall and Aaron Sorkin, and that of “All the President’s Men”, “Fair Game” and “The Ides of March” to lucky casting and the worldwide audience of Hollywood cinema. That the box-office success of the Bourne and Bond films, and of the spy thrillers scripted from Frederick Forsyth, John le Carré and Ian Fleming, is a product of the enormous Hollywood budgets we cannot afford.
And anyway, nobody will let us make such films. All these arguments seem like arguments to me right up to the moment I see how tendentiously Hollywood and British films and series depict the history of the Second World War and our present day, demonising the USSR, Russia, the Russian person, the Soviet soldier, our political leaders of various periods. And the image of the Russian enemy penetrates every genre of Western cinema, comedy included.
Of course, the most tendentious pictures do not receive a distribution certificate, and recently a certificate has also been required for content on digital platforms. Nevertheless Hollywood still rapturously moulds us into caricature idiots or fiends of hell, and that content is available on some of our platforms. Among the latest I have personally seen: the series “Pony”, with a quite accurate picture of Soviet life in the 1960s but a repulsive portrayal of KGB officers as pathological killers and maniacs. Or the film “Sisu”, in which a Finnish soldier, a gold prospector, returns home to find it burned down… by Soviet soldiers. And then, in the spirit of Tarantino, the invulnerable Finn furiously and gleefully hacks Russian soldiers and officers to pieces left and right. The fact that Finland fought on the side of Nazi Germany goes unmentioned by the American-British-Finnish makers.
Bans alone will not do. The best defence is attack. A humanitarian intervention must be met with an intelligent humanitarian answer. The series “GDR” and “Dear Willy” have already appeared, but that is clearly not enough. Nor do those series touch on our present day. So I am sure there will soon be more domestic projects in the political thriller genre.
And we should not be afraid to learn. From the British, for instance, who devote the films “Darkest Hour” and “Into the Storm” to Winston Churchill, and who turn a national catastrophe and an army’s flight into “Dunkirk”, a saga of the courage and mutual support of the British soldier, an epic canvas of the unity of the British nation. We, heirs to our ancestors’ victorious traditions, need to learn to be bolder in depicting the past, the present and the future.
Photos · 1