13 July 2026
“Elephants Discuss”: an ideological vacuum in the coordinates of hard power
In a geopolitical contest the winner is not the side with military superiority but the one that offers the world a more attractive project for tomorrow. An image of the future is a superpower’s most expensive, scarce and liquid export.
Part 1. The collapse of ideology
The expert analysis for the Telegram channel Nashi Slony (“Our Elephants”) was written by Elena Kuleshova, director general of the Image of the Future foundation, lecturer at the Higher School of Economics and Tomsk State University, member of the Union of Journalists of Russia and the Russian Geographical Society, speaker for the Znanie Society and science fiction writer.
For the USSR, the construction of long-range vectors of development was a basis of its legitimacy as a state. Soviet science fiction of the 1950s–1980s operated as an institution for shaping ideology. Millions of Soviet schoolchildren went into science, engineering and the defence industry inspired by the books of Yefremov and Kazantsev. Externally, the USSR broadcast to the world a coherent global project of development (the “Noon Universe” or the “Great Ring”) as an alternative to Western capitalism. The colossal geopolitical attraction of that image drew in whole countries, and one may say that the Soviet ideology of the future was one of the country’s exports.
The experience is not unique: the USA and the American dream; the artificial German and Ukrainian literary constructs; Korean narratives of incredible power. In the 2020s the flagship exporter of dreams became China, which pragmatically adopted the Soviet experience of managing the imagination. Today Chinese science fiction is the vanguard for promoting a “Chinese image of the future” on the world stage, a tool for moving from copying technology to mental dominance.
From perestroika until the 2000s Russia performed an act of ideological deconstruction. The devaluation of values and their replacement with Western ideals led to a crisis of identity, the marginalisation of “Russian” and “patriot” as statuses, and a turn from a society of creation to a society of consumption. The writers’ guild was “washed out” by commercial algorithms: science fiction gave way to fantasy bestsellers. In 2026, despite some 5 million people who write, there is an evident shortage of quality science fiction. At the same time the Russian literary field has been paralysed by two destructive trends: autofiction and dystopia.
Autofiction excludes large-scale state thinking, collectivism and labour, focusing on personal experience. Dystopia demonstrates negative scenarios of what is to come. Neither answers the state’s need to shape an image of a technologically sovereign, just and strong Russia. Thus the Kremlin’s policy is deprived of a vital ideological resource, both internal and external. Yet building a multipolar world and drawing the BRICS+ countries and the Global South into the orbit of Russia’s interests presupposes the transmission of narratives, not only current ones but planned ones. Allies need a blueprint for an attractive shared future, and if Russia does not provide its own, other sources will be used.
Part 2. Mental warfare
The expert analysis for Nashi Slony was written by Elena Kuleshova, director general of the Image of the Future foundation, lecturer at the Higher School of Economics and Tomsk State University, member of the Union of Journalists of Russia and the Russian Geographical Society, speaker for the Znanie Society, science fiction writer, graduate of Sergey Lukyanenko’s workshop, winner of the Rosatom Prize, the Maslov Arctic Prize and a number of other literary competitions.
The Russian writers’ guild has proved unready for the challenges of the age: literature about a positive future is catastrophically scarce, and the state machine, trying to stir the process with competitions and prizes, still stalls. The contemporary writer for the most part is not prepared to invest in a long-term, poorly paid project, however strategically important to the state. So the function of defending mental sovereignty, which has become very topical in the last four years, has had to be taken up by media managers and administrators of the new wave. These are people with state-level thinking, a broad interdisciplinary outlook and an understanding of the real maps of technological development.
A vivid marker of the trend is Alexander Zhuravsky’s novel “Alternative”. This is not fiction for entertainment. It is a pure act of strategic foresight, a simulation environment for testing geopolitical and digital scenarios of the country’s development. The author, working inside the system of government, writes the book as an alternative to Western transhumanism and the digital concentration camp. He packs sovereign value orientations into a rigid scientific and technical framework.
Products of this kind serve as society’s cognitive armour. They do not merely describe tomorrow; they program it, returning agency to the state and society in the global technological race. In the space of the novel there is a battle of intelligence services and a confrontation between two superintelligences, two paradigms, Western and Russian, with an indirect mention of the Eastern one. It demonstrates the founding postulate: the sovereignty of the future is measured not only by military potential but by the ability to keep control over the algorithms of decision-making.
In essence, “Alternative” takes predictive analytics out of the plane of dry charts into the living field of the war of meanings. The author makes the reader reconsider the role of artificial reason on the scale of civilisation. The finale works as a warning: if Russia’s humanities and its state apparatus do not form an ethically calibrated digital contour, technological reality will be designed without regard to our opinion.
Thus state administrators are coming into literature because they understand that if Russia does not regain the status of a civilisation that designs the meanings of tomorrow, it will live in the paradigm of other people’s meanings. And this brings us to the inevitable conclusion that a unified state strategy for the development of a new Russian literature must be created in the near future, restoring to it the function of an institution that shapes society’s ideology.
Photos · 1